[Feral Linguist]

We all know who took Roc v Clips, Math v Hollow, Lux v Calicoe, Pat Stay v Hollohan ........

what about the most debatable battle?

I nominate Chilla v JC

Personally - I have Chilla 3 - 0, hardly a gentleman's 3-0 & his 2nd he absolutely spazzed

Rate my opinion, present another possible battle, and we can amass a catalog

I wool denim for nothin I'm cut from a different cloth!

[iamHBY]

That or Bigg K vs. Illmac.

[Emancee]

Lux vs. Hollow, surely? Although consensus seems to be swinging towards Hollow winning that recently.

[Blaze Won]

Originally Posted by Emancee

Lux vs. Hollow, surely? Although consensus seems to be swinging towards Hollow winning that recently.

At this point...people who still feel like hollow beat Liz are the same goobers that have DNA and Clips in their top5.

[Emancee]

Originally Posted by Blaze Won

At this point...people who still feel like hollow beat Liz are the same goobers that have DNA and Clips in their top5.

Haha! I assume you mean Lux.

I think that me and you have just proved the very point I was making... Highly contentious battle

[Abstrakt]

Originally Posted by Blaze Won

At this point...people who still feel like hollow beat Liz are the same goobers that have DNA and Clips in their top5.

this. lux material has aged much better than hollow's

[Feral Linguist]

Lux' material has indeed - and I would go the same for Bigg K v Illmac - Bigg K's first two rounds have held up much more for me than Illmac's 3rd, plus Illmac had more weak material throughout and K was in rare form.

any others? @iamHBY @Abstrakt @Emancee

I'm halfway stumped on others because I'm a fan of the bodybags, but Stricc v B Dot comes to mind as does Magic v Ty Law

What about Bender v 24/7? Am I alone in giving that a clear win to Bender?

Dialect & Zen v Shufflo?

[sleeping dogs]

hm rum nitty vs iron solomon

[Abstrakt]

aye verb vs hitman

roc vs o red

ave vs nitty

geechi vs surf

nitty vs solomon

just off top

[sleeping dogs]

Originally Posted by Abstrakt

aye verb vs hitman

roc vs o red

ave vs nitty

geechi vs surf

nitty vs solomon

just off top

yeah these are all good. nice call on roc vs o red that's a classic.

[Emancee]

Originally Posted by Feral Linguist

What about Bender v 24/7? Am I alone in giving that a clear win to Bender?

Is that debatable? I thought it was pretty much universally accepted that Bender won that. I remember giving him all three rounds at the time (although I remember it was somewhat debatable).

[Emancee]

Originally Posted by Feral Linguist

Dialect & Zen v Shufflo?

Honestly, the UK title matches have either become pretty clear who won over time or really debatable.

Cee Major's performance against Soul came up randomly the other day and it is really close. I remember at the time giving it to Soul and I think that is correct, but that one is close.I also remember Shox vs. Soul tearing this forum apart on some Biden vs. Trump shit at the time, lol.

I remember that Dialect and Zen had a massively overperforming Dialact and an underperforming Zen, so it depended on whether you thought one person's performance in a double is enough to win a battle. I think most of us went with Shuffarlo, so not that debatable.

[Emancee]

Otherwise from all leagues:

Ness Lee vs. Saurus
Shotty vs. Ars
Day vs Ill Will
Pat vs. Math
Goodz vs Verb although more because neither was able to really get into their groove

All come to mind as ones that split the various forums that I was on at the time apart.

[Emancee]

Originally Posted by Abstrakt

this. lux material has aged much better than hollow's

I might have to go back. It's funny when that happens as trends come and go or stock rises or falls people's opinions on the winners can go a full 360.

[Abstrakt]

Originally Posted by Emancee

I might have to go back. It's funny when that happens as trends come and go or stock rises or falls people's opinions on the winners can go a full 360.

hollow is much stronger live. i feel like rebuttals dont necessarily age that well unless theyre super creative.

if you listen to the material. lux clearly won that battle

[iamHBY]

Originally Posted by sleeping dogs

hm rum nitty vs iron solomon

That's a great pick, both Nitty and Iron were on their A+ game for that battle, and I think it's also the battle that gave the Volume series the reputation it has.